2019-2020

Dallas Stars

GM: TurdFerguson
Eastern Finalist: Ottawa – Hanni

2018-2019

New Jersey Devils

GM: 3thirty

Western Finalist: Chicago – Tilley

2017-2018

Calgary Flames

GM: Cheese

Eastern Finalist: Islanders – TheScorpion

2016-2017

Chicago Blackhawks

GM: Tilley

Eastern Finalist:

2015-2016

New Jersey Devils

GM: 3thirty

Western Finalist:

2014-2015

Pittsburgh Penguins

GM: Goffie

Western Finalist:

2013-2014

Anaheim Ducks

GM: I Wanna Be Like Mikka

Eastern Finalist:

2012-2013

New York Islanders

GM: Simmer2

Western Finalist:

2011-2012

Montreal Canadiens

GM: Superfraggle 

Western Finalist:

2010-2011

Montreal Canadiens

GM: arloinginla 

Western Finalist:

2009-2010

Montreal Canadiens

GM: Simmer2

Western Finalist:

2008-2009

Buffalo Sabres

GM: Looober

Western Finalist:

2007-2008

San Jose Sharks

GM: RT14

Easert Finalist: Carolina – HannaSniper

2006-2007

Minnesota Wild

GM: JiriHrdina

Eastern Finalist:

2005-2006

Atlanta Thrashers

GM: Cheese

Western Finalist:

2004-2005

Boston Bruins

GM: KevanGuy

Western Finalist:

2003-2004

Chicago Blackhawks

GM: Cheese

Eastern Finalist:

2002-2003

Boston Bruins

GM: Cheese

Western Finalist: