2022-2023
New Jersey Devils
GM: Swayze11
Western Finalist: Calgary – I wanna be like Miikka
2021-2022
Dallas Stars
GM: TurdFerguson
Eastern Finalist: Washington – BagoPucks
2020-2021
Minnesota Wild
GM: JiriHrdina
Eastern Finalist: Pittsburgh – Cheese
2019-2020
Dallas Stars
GM: TurdFerguson
Eastern Finalist: Ottawa – Hanni
2018-2019
New Jersey Devils
GM: 3thirty
Western Finalist: Chicago – Tilley
2017-2018
Calgary Flames
GM: Cheese
Eastern Finalist: Islanders – TheScorpion
2016-2017
Chicago Blackhawks
GM: Tilley
Eastern Finalist: Rangers – Flickered Flame
2015-2016
New Jersey Devils
GM: 3thirty
Western Finalist: Los Angeles – dsavillian
2014-2015
Pittsburgh Penguins
GM: Goffie
Western Finalist: Anaheim – I wanna be like Miikka
2013-2014
Anaheim Ducks
GM: I Wanna Be Like Mikka
Eastern Finalist:
2012-2013
New York Islanders
GM: Simmer2
Western Finalist:
2011-2012
Montreal Canadiens
GM: Superfraggle
Western Finalist:
2010-2011
Montreal Canadiens
GM: arloinginla
Western Finalist:
2009-2010
Montreal Canadiens
GM: Simmer2
Western Finalist:
2008-2009
Buffalo Sabres
GM: Looober
Western Finalist:
2007-2008
San Jose Sharks
GM: RT14
Easert Finalist: Carolina – HannaSniper
2006-2007
Minnesota Wild
GM: JiriHrdina
Eastern Finalist:
2005-2006
Atlanta Thrashers
GM: Cheese
Western Finalist:
2004-2005
Boston Bruins
GM: KevanGuy
Western Finalist:
2003-2004
Chicago Blackhawks
GM: Cheese
Eastern Finalist:
2002-2003
Boston Bruins
GM: Cheese
Western Finalist: